Slightly overlooked in all the hoo-ha about the Scottish Parliament election results is Scotland was also voting for local councillors, and it’s been argued before that councillors - not MSP’s or MP’s - have a more direct impact on daily lives.

I’d previously commented that there wasn’t much information available about the various candidates. Judging by some of the comments and e-mails I’ve received, and conversations I’ve held, there’s a general frustration with councillors (and candidate MSP’s for that matter) for relying on flyers-through-the-door rather than grasping the nettle and putting together a useful internet presence, much less cutting through the party-speak and giving us strong reasons to support them other than what colour rosette they’re wearing.

The one exception to this was David Meikle, who I’m actually quite pleased to say is now one of three Pollokshields councillors, and did receive one of my votes. Given my other choices didn’t get through, I like to think it helped him in some way. The full result breakdown is available at Glasgow Council’s website.

I’m hopeful David keeps up his weblog and embraces is at as a useful - and direct - way of staying in touch with his ward. Right now he’s the only Pollokshields councillor with his own internet forum. The SNP councillor Khalil Malik, and the Labour councillor Irfan Rabbani don’t have any presence of note. Heck, google searches come to my own website. Do they really want that? (See for yourself: Rabbani search and Malik search). I’m can’t help but conclude that they’re just riding on the reputation of their party rather than trying to distinguish themselves in their own right?

As to the overall council result, sadly Glasgow council remains with Labour, and by some way too. There’s certainly much much better opposition representation (which is what I was voting for!), but I fear it’s a long way away from moving it to a no-overall-control, much less another party in power. I hope that Labour take note that they’re only just control an absolute majority (56%) of seats. I also hope that Glasgow voters pay particular attention to how they go over the next four years, in particular how tax is dealt with next year, and how they manage the expenditure - especially with the ominous commonwealth games bid.

“Adequate” or “Acceptable” is really no basis, in my view, for re-electing a council, and they’ve barely been that in the few years I’ve been here. They need to be impressing us and deserving of our vote, getting in by default through the fact that they’ve got a red-rosette pinned to their lapel is really not a mandate to be proud of.

5 Responses to “Scottish Elections: Pollokshields ward results”

  1. 1
    Pat the Chooks Says:

    I’ve had a wee look at the results on the Glasgow City Council website. Very good, but could do with identifying the stage at which each candidate was elected. What puzzles me, given that this is an STV election, is how come 77 votes were rejected for “voting for more than one candidate”?

  2. 2
    Pat the Chooks Says:

    Actually, even more praise to Glasgow City Council for the results service. You can download full details of the result in a .zip file, including a ballot file which can be loaded into the excellent OpenSTV programme and you can re-run the count for yourself. Using this programme, you can even examine each individual (anonymised) ballot and see where people put their preferences and how many they used. Great stuff, must suggest it to my local returning officer.

  3. 3
    Richard Says:

    Thanks for the tip Pat - I’ve just downloaded OpenSTV (Thankfully there’s a Mac version :-) and run it through. Impressive stuff, and Glasgow council are certainly deserving of a lot of praise for making it all available. The download for each ward also has an .HTML ‘rendered’ result which don’t require special software.

    I still worry a little with how ’surplus’ votes are chosen or rounded up for 2nd preference and so forth, but interesting to see how the results moved around and shaped up. Useful information, software and service that merits a bit more attention :-)

  4. 4
    Jonathan Says:

    An excellent wee tip for the council results, thank you very much Pat & Richard.

    An lovely insight into the voters’ psyche. Who are the 13 people in Govan ward who had ‘Scottish Unionist - Proudly Scottish, Proudly British’ as 1st pref and SNP as 2nd? And the 29 with vice versa? :)

    I fear I shall spend hours pouring over these tables - thanks again!

  5. 5
    David Says:

    I was really impressed with David Meikle’s blog as well. It certainly made my life a bit easier in terms of getting in touch with him during the election campaign. He’s started one on our website at g41.org.uk as well. None of the other new councillors have done that yet.

Leave a Reply

Please be sure to read the comment policy before posting.